Written by
Phi Management
Leadership assessment and development specialists
Short answer
Feedback looks back at what someone has already done and evaluates it; feedforward asks for suggestions about what they could do differently in future. Research shows feedback improves performance on average but makes it worse in over a third of cases, often by drawing attention to the self. Feedforward works best for building a chosen behaviour, while feedback remains necessary for standards and accountability.
In this article
- What is the difference between feedforward and feedback?
- Where did the idea of feedforward come from?
- What does the research say about feedback?
- When should a manager use feedforward vs feedback?
- How does a manager run a feedforward conversation?
- What are the limits of feedforward?
- How does Phi Management help managers move from feedback to feedforward?
- Frequently asked questions
- The bottom line
Feedforward vs feedback is a choice between two kinds of developmental conversation: one looks back at what someone did, the other asks for ideas about what they could do next. This guide explains how each works, where feedforward came from, what the research says about feedback, and how a manager decides which to use and runs a feedforward conversation well.
What is the difference between feedforward and feedback?
Feedback evaluates past performance; feedforward offers suggestions for future behaviour. Marshall Goldsmith, who popularised the technique, describes feedforward as giving someone “suggestions for the future” and helping “as much as they can” [Source: Marshall Goldsmith].
Feedback is the default in most organisations, yet it often fails to land. Gallup found that “only 14% of employees strongly agree their performance reviews inspire them to improve” [Source: Gallup 2019]. That is the gap feedforward tries to close.
| Feedback | Feedforward | |
|---|---|---|
| Time focus | What already happened | What could happen next |
| Typical question | “How did that go?” | “What could I do differently next time?” |
| Who can give it | Usually someone who saw the work | Anyone who knows about the task |
| Main risk | The person defends the past | Suggestions stay generic or are ignored |
| Best for | Accountability, standards, recognition | Building a behaviour, preparing for a challenge |
| How it is received | Often personally | Less personally, in Goldsmith’s experience |
The difference in feedforward vs feedback is less about tone than about direction. Goldsmith puts the logic in one line: “We can change the future. We can’t change the past.”
Where did the idea of feedforward come from?
Feedforward entered management practice through two routes: Marshall Goldsmith’s group exercise and Avraham Kluger and Dina Nir’s Feedforward Interview. Goldsmith reports having “observed more than thirty thousand leaders” take part in his exercise, and says their one-word reactions were almost always extremely positive [Source: Marshall Goldsmith].
In Goldsmith’s version, each person picks one behaviour they would like to change, asks a colleague for two suggestions for the future, listens without commenting, and says thank you. Then the roles swap and each person moves on to someone new.
The second route came from research. Avraham Kluger, a professor of organisational behaviour at the Hebrew University School of Business, developed the Feedforward Interview with Dina Nir “as a substitute for performance appraisal” [Source: Institute of Coaching]. Kluger is also known for earlier research, with Angelo DeNisi, on how feedback affects performance, covered in the next section.
The two share a premise but differ in form: Goldsmith’s exercise is quick and peer-to-peer, while the interview is a one-to-one alternative to the appraisal meeting.
What does the research say about feedback?
Feedback helps on average, but it often backfires. Kluger and DeNisi’s 1996 meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin, as summarised by the Psych Safety Field Guide, covered 607 effect sizes and 23,663 observations: feedback raised performance on average (d = .41) but made it worse in over a third of cases [Source: Psych Safety Field Guide].
Their explanation is about attention. Feedback helps when it keeps attention on the task and backfires when it shifts attention to the self, diverting effort into self-evaluation, defence and emotion [Source: Psych Safety Field Guide].
That finding is not limited to criticism. The Institute of Coaching notes that Kluger’s research with DeNisi showed “even positive feedback can be detrimental to performance” [Source: Institute of Coaching].
Two practical lessons follow for managers:
- Keep the conversation about the task. Comments about the person invite defence.
- Do not assume more feedback is better. The same meta-analysis that found a positive average also found a large share of interventions that made things worse.
Feedforward is one response to this problem. A suggestion about next time is hard to hear as a verdict on who you are.
When should a manager use feedforward vs feedback?
Use feedforward to build a specific behaviour or prepare for a coming challenge; use feedback when standards, accountability or recognition of past work are at stake. Frequency matters as much as type: Gallup reports that “nearly half of employees say they receive feedback from their manager a few times a year or less” [Source: Gallup 2019].
Gallup also found that employees who receive weekly rather than annual feedback are “5.2x more likely to strongly agree that they receive meaningful feedback”. Regular, short conversations matter, whichever direction they face.
| Situation | Better choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A missed deadline or broken standard | Feedback | The facts of what happened need to be agreed |
| A leader wants to listen better in meetings | Feedforward | One behaviour, many possible ideas |
| Preparing for a difficult presentation | Feedforward | The event has not happened yet |
| Recognising a strong piece of work | Feedback | Specific praise anchors what to repeat |
| Peers with no formal authority over each other | Feedforward | Suggestions need no right to evaluate |
| A formal appraisal or rating | Feedback, then feedforward | Agree the record first, then plan forward |
For senior leaders, the two often work in sequence. A structured process such as 360-degree feedback for senior leaders gives an evidence base about the past. Feedforward then turns that evidence into practical next steps, often recorded in an individual development plan.
How does a manager run a feedforward conversation?
Name one behaviour, ask for two suggestions, listen without judging, and say thank you. In Goldsmith’s group exercise each exchange takes about two minutes; the exercise “typically lasts for 10-15 minutes, and the average participant has 6-7 dialogue sessions” [Source: Marshall Goldsmith].
A manager can adapt the same steps to a one-to-one or team setting:
- Choose one behaviour. It should be specific and visible to others, for example “summarising decisions at the end of meetings”.
- Ask for the future only. Request two ideas for next time. Goldsmith’s rules allow no feedback about the past, even between people who have worked together.
- Listen and take notes. Participants “are not allowed to comment on the suggestions in any way”. No defending, and no explaining why an idea will not work.
- Say thank you. Thanks is the only reply, which keeps the exchange short and safe.
- Choose and commit. Afterwards, pick the one or two ideas worth testing and agree a date to review progress.
The hardest step for most managers is the third. Resisting the urge to explain or justify is what stops the conversation sliding back into feedback.
What are the limits of feedforward?
Feedforward does not replace feedback on past performance, and its evidence base is still developing. Goldsmith himself says his intent is “not to imply that leaders should never give feedback”, and he does not argue that performance appraisals should be abandoned [Source: Marshall Goldsmith].
The research on the Feedforward Interview is promising but young. A 2019 review in the Journal of Management Development notes that “recent research has found” the technique can be used to develop employees on the job, but that “the mechanisms and boundary conditions of the FFI-performance relationship are unexplored” [Source: Budworth, Harrison and Chummar 2019].
Four limits are worth keeping in mind:
- Some things must be named. Misconduct, safety issues and missed commitments need direct feedback, not suggestions.
- Generic ideas add little. Feedforward depends on people who understand the task well enough to suggest something useful.
- It can avoid hard truths. A manager who only ever asks for ideas may never address a pattern the employee cannot see.
- It needs follow-through. Suggestions without a review date rarely change behaviour.
The sensible conclusion from the feedforward vs feedback research is balance, not replacement. Use feedback to agree what happened, and feedforward to shape what happens next.
How does Phi Management help managers move from feedback to feedforward?
Phi Management runs Feedback to Feedforward, a two-day, in-person programme in its accelerator programmes range for newly promoted and mid-level managers. It teaches the feedforward technique alongside giving and receiving feedback, building a feedback culture and handling common feedback challenges. Participants leave with a personalised action plan.
For managers who want a broader coaching approach, the two-day Coaching for Leaders programme covers transformative questions, active listening and giving constructive feedback. Managing Tough Conversations focuses on the difficult discussions where feedback is unavoidable.
For individual leaders, 360Quest feedback compares self-perception with how colleagues see them, followed by a one-to-one feedback session with a Phi executive coach and a personalised development plan. Executive coaching supports senior and emerging leaders one to one. Read more about who Phi Management is.
Frequently asked questions
Is feedforward just positive feedback? No. Positive feedback still evaluates the past, and Kluger’s research with DeNisi found that even praise can harm performance when it draws attention to the self rather than the task. Feedforward makes no judgement about what happened. It asks for ideas about what could happen next, on a behaviour the person has chosen. That is one reason it tends to feel less personal. The suggestions may still be challenging, but they are framed as options for the future rather than a verdict on the person, which makes them easier to hear and act on.
Can feedforward replace the annual performance review? Not on its own. Kluger and Nir developed the Feedforward Interview as a substitute for performance appraisal, but most organisations still need a record of past results for pay, promotion and accountability. A practical approach is to keep both and to separate them. Agree the facts of the year in a feedback conversation, then hold a distinct forward-looking conversation about development. Mixing the two in one meeting tends to pull attention back to the rating, which is exactly the self-focused reaction the research warns about.
How often should a manager use feedforward? Little and often works better than a single long session. Gallup found that weekly feedback was linked to far higher agreement that feedback is meaningful than annual feedback, and the same logic is likely to apply to forward-looking conversations. A short feedforward request can fit into a regular one-to-one or the end of a project review. The key is to focus on one behaviour at a time, act on the best ideas, and return to the same behaviour a few weeks later to see whether anything has changed.
The bottom line
Feedback and feedforward do different jobs. Feedback agrees what happened and holds standards; feedforward generates ideas for what happens next, with less risk of defensiveness. The research suggests managers should give feedback with care and use feedforward far more often. To build these skills in your managers, talk to Phi Management.
Sources
- Marshall Goldsmith · marshallgoldsmith.com
- Gallup 2019 · gallup.com
- Institute of Coaching · instituteofcoaching.org
- Psych Safety Field Guide · explore.psychsafety.com
- Budworth, Harrison and Chummar 2019 · emerald.com